Our News
Latest from the Litigation Impact Tracker: 9 new traces, 14 November 2026
14 November 2026
What followed climate rulings, as reported in the sources: 9 new traces added to the tracker, from Greenpeace Nordic Ass'n v. Ministry of…, Greenpeace Nordic and Nature & Youth v. Energy…,…
Latest from the Litigation Impact Tracker. The tracker follows what happens after a climate ruling: laws and policies that change, courts that rely on it, companies, governments and campaigns that respond. This batch adds 9 new traces across 6 cases.
Six years on, Norway's Supreme Court holds the state to its 2020 Arctic oil ruling: climate effects must be assessed when a field is approved
Norway's Supreme Court annulled on 13 November 2026 the approvals of three North Sea fields for lack of a proper climate assessment, and built part of the reasoning on its own 2020 plenary judgment in the Arctic oil case. In 2020 the state won, but the Court said global climate effects would be assessed later, when a development plan is submitted. The 2026 judgment reads the 2020 majority as presupposing exactly that, and uses its statements that courts must review procedure 'intensively' under the environmental clause of the Constitution (Article 112) and that the climate effect of a project 'is not geographically limited'.
Case: Greenpeace Nordic Ass'n v. Ministry of Petroleum and Energy (People v Arctic Oil) · 13 November 2026 · Open the trace
Aker BP and Equinor keep the three oil fields on schedule despite the ruling; campaigners weigh suing the companies
Aker BP and Equinor said on 13 November 2026 that the Supreme Court ruling annulling the approvals of Breidablikk, Tyrving and Yggdrasil does not change their plans: Tyrving and Breidablikk keep producing, and Yggdrasil, the largest current investment on the Norwegian shelf, is still due to start in summer 2027. The Court had said the ruling does not bind the companies, which were not parties. The lawyer for Greenpeace Nordic and Natur og Ungdom told Reuters the groups will now consider suing the operators to halt output.
Case: Greenpeace Nordic and Nature & Youth v. Energy Ministry (The North Sea Fields Case) · 13 November 2026 · Open the trace
Norway's Supreme Court reads the ICJ climate opinion as not requiring a carbon-budget test for exported oil and gas
Norway's Supreme Court held unanimously on 13 November 2026 that the state need not test the combustion emissions of a new oil field against the remaining global carbon budget. The environmental groups had relied on the ICJ advisory opinion of July 2025. The Court accepts, citing paragraph 231, that the Paris temperature goal creates obligations, but reads paragraphs 233 and 270 as saying those obligations are met through each state's own national targets and cuts. It adds that the general due-diligence duty the ICJ found in customary law is too general to carry so specific a requirement. The appeal court below had required a carbon-budget assessment; that part is overturned.
Case: Obligations of States in respect of Climate Change (ICJ Advisory Opinion) · 13 November 2026 · Open the trace
Norway's Supreme Court applies the Strasbourg Greenpeace Nordic judgment to the approval stage of oil fields
Norway's Supreme Court held on 13 November 2026 that, before a plan to develop an oil or gas field is approved, the authorities must assess whether it is compatible with national and international duties to act against climate change. It takes this from the European Court of Human Rights judgment of 28 October 2025 in Greenpeace Nordic and Others v. Norway, paragraphs 314 to 319: Article 8 requires an environmental assessment that is 'adequate, timely and comprehensive' and that at least quantifies the emissions from burning the oil and gas, at home and abroad. The Supreme Court reads those paragraphs as speaking about the development-plan stage. The three field approvals at issue were annulled.
Case: Greenpeace Nordic and Others v. Norway · 13 November 2026 · Open the trace
UK government weighs removing the cost cap that made the Finch climate case possible
The UK Ministry of Justice is holding private meetings on removing or weakening the cap on legal costs for environmental claims, the Guardian reported on 13 November 2026, citing environmental lawyers. The options described include doubling the cap at each stage, lifting it where a court finds 'misuse of judicial review', and exposing crowdfunded groups to costs of up to 70% of what they raise. Sarah Finch, whose challenge to a Surrey oil well led the Supreme Court in 2024 to require that burning-stage emissions be assessed, says her group 'would have never brought this legal action' without the cap. The government says it has no plans to remove protection for 'well-founded claims'.
Case: R (Finch) v. Surrey County Council · 13 November 2026 · Open the trace
Norway's Supreme Court rejects a carbon-budget duty drawn from KlimaSeniorinnen
Norway's Supreme Court refused on 13 November 2026 to derive from the KlimaSeniorinnen judgment a duty to assess a new oil field's emissions against remaining carbon budgets. Greenpeace Nordic and Natur og Ungdom had invoked paragraph 550 of the Strasbourg judgment of 9 April 2024, the passage on carbon budgets. The Court answers that 'such an obligation cannot be derived' from it, and that nothing else in Article 8 of the European Convention points that way. The approvals of the three fields were still annulled, but on other grounds.
Case: Verein KlimaSeniorinnen Schweiz and Others v. Switzerland · 13 November 2026 · Open the trace
Norway will redo the climate assessment of three oil fields after losing in the Supreme Court, and says approvals will get stricter
Norway's energy minister Terje Aasland said on 13 November 2026 that the government will correct 'as soon as possible' the flaws in the approvals of the Breidablikk, Tyrving and Yggdrasil fields, and that the basis for future approvals 'will become more extensive and stricter'. He was answering the Supreme Court ruling of the same day, which annulled the three approvals because burning-stage emissions had not been assessed together with the rest of Norwegian production. He also said production will not stop, that 'Norwegian oil policy stands', and gave no timetable for the new assessments.
Norway's Greens take the oil-field ruling into the state budget talks and demand a production halt
Hours after the Supreme Court annulled the approvals of three North Sea fields on 13 November 2026, the Green Party (MDG) said it will bring the ruling into its ongoing budget negotiations with the government and demand that production stop until the law is complied with. The Socialist Left said the ruling must have consequences for further development on the shelf. The Progress Party called the requirement 'meaningless' and asked the government to make sure no project is delayed. The energy minister replied that it would be 'strange' for Parliament to go further than the Court.
Norway's Supreme Court leans on the ICJ climate opinion to require oil-field approvals to count cumulative emissions
Norway's Supreme Court ruled on 13 November 2026 that the approvals of three North Sea oil and gas fields are invalid, because the climate assessment looked at each field alone and not together with all other approved production on the Norwegian shelf. The six-judge majority cites the ICJ advisory opinion of 23 July 2025 (paragraphs 272-276), where states must 'assess the possible cumulative effects' of activities under their control. It says the opinion does not decide how the EU environmental assessment directive is read, but rests on 'a corresponding line of thought': a permit cannot be judged in a vacuum. The five dissenting judges read the same opinion the other way, as leaving states wide room and allowing the cumulative view to be taken at a higher level, not project by project.
Explore and follow
Consult the Litigation Impact Tracker for every trace, with its sources and case.
To get new traces by email, follow the tracker ; for all Climpact news, subscribe to Climpact Radar , the project newsletter.
Every trace is something reported, with its source, not something proven by Climpact.