Climpact
There Is No Silver Bullet: Paul Mougeolle on Taking France and TotalEnergies to Court
20 November 2026
Paul Mougeolle of Notre Affaire à Tous, who helped craft the climate lawsuit against TotalEnergies, on the June ruling in Paris, the road from L'Affaire du Siècle, and why no single case can make…
Notre Affaire à Tous v. TotalEnergies, from the first letter to the ruling
On 25 June 2026 the Judicial Court of Paris held that TotalEnergies had breached its duty of vigilance and ordered the company to complete its vigilance plan within six months, including its scope 3 emissions. TotalEnergies has appealed, and the case returns to court in January 2027. In this episode the CLIMPACT team talks with Paul Mougeolle, strategic advisor at Notre Affaire à Tous, who helped craft the lawsuit and pleaded for the coalition of plaintiffs at the two-day hearing in February. We go back to L'Affaire du Siècle, follow the TotalEnergies case from its first letter to the company to the decision, and ask what comes next.
IN THIS EPISODE L'Affaire du Siècle: suing the French State when domestic climate litigation was still seen as a little crazy Enforcement in instalments, and how French courts, traditionally seen as conservative, began to look forward The Fair Share Trial before the Council of State, and the weight of KlimaSeniorinnen and the ICJ advisory opinion TotalEnergies: the duty of vigilance law, the battle over jurisdiction, the appeal and the two-day hearing What the decision gives litigators and campaigners, and what they will ask for next Shielding companies from climate suits: New Zealand's tort liability law and the deletion of the CSDDD transition plan duty Climate justice and social justice in France, and the just transition A judicial architecture that complements the Paris Agreement The readings Paul recommends, and the case he would come back to check in ten years
VOICES Paul Mougeolle , strategic advisor at Notre Affaire à Tous Giuseppe Naglieri , Principal Investigator of CLIMPACT Carlotta Garofalo and Enrico Buono , postdoctoral researchers in comparative law Gabriel Rojas and Ciro Saracino , doctoral researchers
ABOUT THE PODCAST CLIMPACT Conversations follows climate litigation beyond the gavel. Every month we take one question at a time with the scholars, lawyers and people who brought the cases. If there is a case or a person you would like to hear, write to us.
Website: https://www.climpact.it Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/climpactproject
CLIMPACT , Charting the Landscape of Climate Litigation Impacts, is based at the University of Bari and funded by the Italian Ministry of University and Research through the Italian Fund for Science (Starting Grant).